Hi,

On Wed, Apr 23, 2008 at 10:17 PM, Lap1994 wrote:

Here, a list of things GIMP do not have, in my mind:

A ellipse tool to draw ellipse, as a rectangle tool to draw rectangle, and a polygon tool to draw ah, you know.

You are currently expected to use the appropriate selection tools and then fill the resulting selection.
see
http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=65197 for a related bug report.

A method to draw text using a system like boards systems to change text properties, font, style, size stuff. Like using bold here! A way to draw curves.

Do you mean, like GIMP's paths tool? (key shortcut = B)

A way to deny modifications in a layer, and a way to change this property A method to organize layers.
A method to assign a same mask to various layer modifying one mask A gradient color with more colors. Like Flash where you can set more than two colors in a gradient.

Easily done -- a gradient can have however many colors you want. 1. Bring up the Gradients dialog
2. Create a new gradient
3. Double-click on it to edit it
4. Make the necessary changes (you can use 'split uniformly' to split a given gradient segment into several segments. If you can find a menu item like this but it doesn't read sensibly, then that is a bug in the translation, which you should report.)

I key shortcut to stop drawing layer outline

You can assign a key shortcut yourself.

Here ends my list.

More any suggestion well capable to pass non-noticed? Foward here. --
Check my gallery!
http://lap1994.deviantart.com

On Wed, 2008-04-23 at 09:47 -0300, Lap1994 wrote:

A ellipse tool to draw ellipse, as a rectangle tool to draw rectangle, and a polygon tool to draw ah, you know.

You do this by stroking selections. The Rectangular and Elliptical selections will cover the first two, and the Paths tool (converted to a selection) will cover the latter.

On the other hand, I once wrote a plugin (GFXShapes) for creating a number of basic shapes. It was part of a set of plugins I called the Graphics Muse tools. It's written for GIMP 2.2 but it works (as far as I can tell) under GIMP 2.4. You can grab a copy of the source code from my web site: http://www.ximba.org/sw/gfxmuse/GFXMuseTools-3.0.0B2.tar.gz The web site with docs is: http://www.ximba.org/gfxmuse/gfxmuse.html

Not to mention GFig, which draws lots of shapes for you: Filters->Render->GFig.

A method to draw text using a system like boards systems to change text properties, font, style, size stuff. Like using bold here!

GIMP doesn't do that currently. I'd cringe at adding it to the core system since I consider that feature-creep. But providing the right API for a plugin to handle it would be a nice addition.

A way to draw curves.

Use the Paths tool. Click once to drop an endpoint to the curve. Click again to drop the second. In the Tool Options, switch to Edit mode and then click on each end point and drag out to get an anchor point to adjust the shape of the curve. Then use Stoke Path in the Tool Options.

A way to deny modifications in a layer, and a way to change this property

That would be nice. GIMP currently does not suppor this in 2.4.

A method to organize layers.

A plugin could do that pretty easily. Define "organize". Remember that you can drag layers up and down the stack in the Layers dialog. You can align layers using the Alignment Tool from the toolbox. GFXLayers in my Graphics Muse Tools also does this though I think the Alignment tool is probably a simpler to use interface.

A method to assign a same mask to various layer modifying one mask

Not sure what you mean here, but you can copy and paste masks. You can't link a single mask to multiple layers, however. Linking masks to multiple layers might be a nice feature.

A gradient color with more colors. Like Flash where you can set more than two colors in a gradient.

You can set as many colors as you want in gradients. Use the gradient editor ("New gradient" button the Gradients dialog).

I key shortcut to stop drawing layer outline

You can dynamically set keyboard shortcuts for any menu item that does not already have one: File->Keyboard Shortcuts (from the Toolbox menus). Find your item, click on it and then type the keyboard shortcut. For example, change View->Show Layer Boundary to use Ctrl-? (re: Ctrl-Shift-/) you just find View->Show Layer Boundary in the Configure Keyboard Shortcuts dialog, click on it and then type Ctrl-Shift-/.

Yep, Lap,

All of these tools/capabilities are already part of GIMP. Ensure that you have the latest version, but most of these have been there from the start.

Nathan

On Wed, Apr 23, 2008 at 8:45 AM, Michael J. Hammel < mjhammel@graphics-muse.org> wrote:

On Wed, 2008-04-23 at 09:47 -0300, Lap1994 wrote:

A ellipse tool to draw ellipse, as a rectangle tool to draw rectangle,

and

a polygon tool to draw ah, you know.

You do this by stroking selections. The Rectangular and Elliptical selections will cover the first two, and the Paths tool (converted to a selection) will cover the latter.

On the other hand, I once wrote a plugin (GFXShapes) for creating a number of basic shapes. It was part of a set of plugins I called the Graphics Muse tools. It's written for GIMP 2.2 but it works (as far as I can tell) under GIMP 2.4. You can grab a copy of the source code from my web site: http://www.ximba.org/sw/gfxmuse/GFXMuseTools-3.0.0B2.tar.gz The web site with docs is: http://www.ximba.org/gfxmuse/gfxmuse.html

Not to mention GFig, which draws lots of shapes for you: Filters->Render->GFig.

A method to draw text using a system like boards systems to change text properties, font, style, size stuff. Like using bold here!

GIMP doesn't do that currently. I'd cringe at adding it to the core system since I consider that feature-creep. But providing the right API for a plugin to handle it would be a nice addition.

A way to draw curves.

Use the Paths tool. Click once to drop an endpoint to the curve. Click again to drop the second. In the Tool Options, switch to Edit mode and then click on each end point and drag out to get an anchor point to adjust the shape of the curve. Then use Stoke Path in the Tool Options.

A way to deny modifications in a layer, and a way to change this

property

That would be nice. GIMP currently does not suppor this in 2.4.

A method to organize layers.

A plugin could do that pretty easily. Define "organize". Remember that you can drag layers up and down the stack in the Layers dialog. You can align layers using the Alignment Tool from the toolbox. GFXLayers in my Graphics Muse Tools also does this though I think the Alignment tool is probably a simpler to use interface.

A method to assign a same mask to various layer modifying one mask

Not sure what you mean here, but you can copy and paste masks. You can't link a single mask to multiple layers, however. Linking masks to multiple layers might be a nice feature.

A gradient color with more colors. Like Flash where you can set more

than

two colors in a gradient.

You can set as many colors as you want in gradients. Use the gradient editor ("New gradient" button the Gradients dialog).

I key shortcut to stop drawing layer outline

You can dynamically set keyboard shortcuts for any menu item that does not already have one: File->Keyboard Shortcuts (from the Toolbox menus). Find your item, click on it and then type the keyboard shortcut. For example, change View->Show Layer Boundary to use Ctrl-? (re: Ctrl-Shift-/) you just find View->Show Layer Boundary in the Configure Keyboard Shortcuts dialog, click on it and then type Ctrl-Shift-/.

-- Michael J. Hammel Principal Software Engineer
mjhammel@graphics-muse.org
http://graphics-muse.org

------------------------------------------------------------------------------ The time it will take before the breadth of human knowledge is available on
the Internet is precisely inverse to the amount of time it took to remove
it from cable television. -- Michael J. Hammel

_______________________________________________ Gimp-user mailing list
Gimp-user@lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU
https://lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU/mailman/listinfo/gimp-user

Michael J. Hammel wrote:

A method to draw text using a system like boards systems to change text properties, font, style, size stuff. Like using bold here!

GIMP doesn't do that currently. I'd cringe at adding it to the core system since I consider that feature-creep. But providing the right API for a plugin to handle it would be a nice addition.

You consider a proper text tool in the core feature-creep? I find that odd. Every major player in this software category implements a tool of this sort as a matter of course and in the core. Do you VERY rarely use text in GIMP?

Granted, you do mention a plugin, but if you make it a plugin, it will not be as fast or as straightforward to use, almost like an afterthought. Should the user really have to open a plugin window just to add a word? Modularity is great, but text ranks on the order of a paintbrush tool in importance IMHO.

Ben

Good point, probably - but Inkscape does an extremely good job at working with text and SVG along with the vector lines can be imported and manipulated in the GIMP. That's not too bad. I think.

Nathan

On Wed, Apr 23, 2008 at 7:49 PM, Ben Walker wrote:

Michael J. Hammel wrote:

A method to draw text using a system like boards systems to change text properties, font, style, size stuff. Like using bold here!

GIMP doesn't do that currently. I'd cringe at adding it to the core system since I consider that feature-creep. But providing the right API for a plugin to handle it would be a nice addition.

You consider a proper text tool in the core feature-creep? I find that odd. Every major player in this software category implements a tool of this sort as a matter of course and in the core. Do you VERY rarely use text in GIMP?

Granted, you do mention a plugin, but if you make it a plugin, it will not be as fast or as straightforward to use, almost like an afterthought. Should the user really have to open a plugin window just to add a word? Modularity is great, but text ranks on the order of a paintbrush tool in importance IMHO.

Ben

_______________________________________________ Gimp-user mailing list
Gimp-user@lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU
https://lists.XCF.Berkeley.EDU/mailman/listinfo/gimp-user

On Wed, 2008-04-23 at 19:49 -0600, Ben Walker wrote:

You consider a proper text tool in the core feature-creep?

In a raster image editor, yes.

I find that
odd. Every major player in this software category implements a tool of this sort as a matter of course and in the core.

I can't speak for the developers, but I'm fairly certain the "major players" have never been the compelling reason to implement anything in the GIMP. If open source simply followed the major players, Firefox would have to be embedded in the Linux kernel.

Do you VERY rarely use
text in GIMP?

Not that much, no. Certainly not for anything that requires extensive formatting on a single line. If I really need to do fancy, extended text with large amounts of character formatting on multiple lines of text, I use a more appropriate tool (OpenOffice, Inkscape or Scribus come to mind). I prefer to rasterize the text and let the GIMP format the text in the way raster editors do best - pixel by pixel. See the section on Type Effects in my book.

In my (extremely humble) opinion, just because you can hammer a nail with a pair of pliers doesn't make it the best tool for the job.

Granted, you do mention a plugin, but if you make it a plugin, it will not be as fast or as straightforward to use, almost like an afterthought.

Depends on the API. There is nothing preventing it from from being tightly integrated with the core even as a plugin except the structure of the API. As an example, you can tightly integrate Java plugins into core Java applications using JPF (not that I like Java all the much, I just happen to forced into using it at work at the moment).

That said, the current GIMP API does have limitations that would probably prevent such a plugin. I'm not clear on how this might change with GEGL. I'm kind of out of the loop on GEGL capabilities right now (just not enough time to keep up with everything).

Should the user really have to open a plugin window just to add a word?

You already open a dialog to add text. But adding text without the dialog would be nice too. I'm just not in favor of implementing a full scale text editor with extensive character and paragraph formatting support in the core of a raster image editor. There are more appropriate tools for that.

A better solution would probably be a common interface for tools like Inkscape, Scribus and GIMP to share data, probably vector data in XML format. Then you can use Inkscape or Scribus to do your text editing and import it into GIMP using this TBD common interface.

Keep in mind, these are just random thoughts. I'm not a developer of the GIMP. Just a fan.

Modularity is great, but text ranks on the order of a paintbrush tool in importance IMHO.

Fair enough. I just have a different HO. :-)

On Wed, Apr 23, 2008 at 9:47 PM, Michael J. Hammel wrote:

On Wed, 2008-04-23 at 19:49 -0600, Ben Walker wrote: > You consider a proper text tool in the core feature-creep?

In a raster image editor, yes.

Personally I disagree - I'm eagerly awaiting the GSoC update to the text tool, and I hope it results in an improvement in 2.8. I certainly use workarounds like styling text in other (usually vector) programs and rasterizing it in GIMP - however, I do consider them to be workarounds as opposed to solutions.

I agree that some type of third-party type-styling tool would be optimal (anyone ever use TypeStyler on old-world mac?), but I just don't see anything materializing soon. In lieu of that, a more robust type handling in GIMP would be much appreciated. Even simple things like rotating text and still being able to edit the content would make my life a lot simpler.

As a freelancer, I use GIMP as a design tool for a number of reasons. The first is that I enjoy using it more than the Other Program. The Python interface is another. FOSS is another important reason. The fact that I run linux as my primary OS helps too :) And I do love GIMP - but all of that aside, in the graphic design world text is now just as integral to a production image as a photograph and should be treated accordingly. Whether or not this is accomplished through a port of the text tool to cairo/pango or the addition of a plugin is up to the (most highly respected) developers, but I think enough of us are wishing for it to make it happen. GD work (in my experience) is almost always verging on a train wreck - an improvement in GIMP's text tool would certainly help me keep it on the rails :)

Chris

On Wednesday 23 April 2008, Michael J. Hammel wrote:

the GIMP. If open source simply followed the major players, Firefox would have to be embedded in the Linux kernel.

That's a bit of a straw man argument, and you know it. Firefox and IE are nearly identical, UI-wise.